Battle of Xiangzhou (759) — the same event in Old Book of Tang and New Book of Tang

Old Book of Tang: At Xiangzhou, Guo Ziyi and others of the field headquarters fought Shi Siming and were at a disadvantage; the nine-jiedushi army…

What each source says

Old Book of Tang (Jiu Tangshu), Annals · AD 759 · 相州

At Xiangzhou, Guo Ziyi and others of the field headquarters fought Shi Siming and were at a disadvantage; the nine-jiedushi army collapsed, and Guo Ziyi cut the Heyang Bridge and held Dongjing.

壬申,相州行營郭子儀等與賊史思明戰,王師不利,九節度兵潰,子儀斷河陽橋,以餘眾保東京。
Location: 舊唐書 卷10 乾元2年

New Book of Tang (Xin Tangshu), Annals · AD 759 · 相州

The army of the Nine Jiedushi collapsed at the Fu River, and Shi Siming killed An Qingxu (the great defeat at Xiangzhou).

九節度之師潰于滏水。史思明殺安慶緒
Location: 新唐書 卷006 肅宗·代宗 乾元2年3月

Place: 韓陵(安陽) · 鄴

Show on the map — open Old Book of Tang (Jiu Tangshu), Annals