Battle of Nanpi (205) — the same event in Records of the Three Kingdoms and Zizhi Tongjian

Records of the Three Kingdoms: Cao Cao struck Yuan Tan, beheaded him, and executed his wife and children; Jizhou was pacified.; Zizhi Tongjian: In…

What each source says

Records of the Three Kingdoms (Sanguozhi) · AD 205 · 南皮

Cao Cao struck Yuan Tan, beheaded him, and executed his wife and children; Jizhou was pacified.

十年春正月,攻譚,破之,斬譚,誅其妻子,冀州平。
Location: 魏書 武帝紀 (卷01) 建安10년

Zizhi Tongjian (Comprehensive Mirror) · AD 205 · 南皮

In the first month Cao Cao attacked Nanpi. When Yuan Tan came out and fought, many of his soldiers died, and Cao Cao considered withdrawing; but on the advice of Cao Shun he himself beat the drum and attacked, taking the city. Yuan Tan fled and was beheaded.

春,正月,曹操攻南皮,袁譚出戰,士卒多死。
Location: 資治通鑑 卷064 (원문 단락 #5233, 205년)

Place: 南皮

Show on the map — open Records of the Three Kingdoms (Sanguozhi)