Cholula (1519) — the same event in Bernal Díaz, True History of the Conquest of New Spain, Cortés, Letters from Mexico and Florentine Codex

Bernal Díaz, True History of the Conquest of New Spain: On Montezuma's orders a plot to kill the Spaniards was made at Cholula, and its outcome…

What each source says

Bernal Díaz, True History of the Conquest of New Spain · AD 1519 · Cholula

On Montezuma's orders a plot to kill the Spaniards was made at Cholula, and its outcome unfolded (chapter 83 title).

If perchance we had not inflicted that punishment, our lives would have been in great danger on account of the squadrons and companies of Mexican and Cholulan…
Location: Maudslay vol.2 ch.LXXXIII–LXXXIV

Cortés, Letters from Mexico · AD 1519 · Cholula

Having obtained intelligence of the plot, Cortés imprisoned the chiefs and gave the signal by gunshot to attack first; more than 3,000 died in two hours (the editor treats this massacre as the greatest point of debate).

It was done in this wise, that, after I had taken these lords, and left them bound in the chamber, I mounted a horse, and ordered the musket to be fired, and…
Location: Letter 2, MacNutt vol.1 OCR line 9281

Florentine Codex · AD 1519 · Cholula

When the Spaniards go from Tlaxcala to Cholula and arrive there, they carry out a great massacre of the people of Cholula

hicieron gran matanza en los de Choluíla
Location: t.2 Lib.8 cap.7 (p.284)

Where the sources differ

A and B are two of the sources listed above.

On what pointSource ASource BWhat differs (in Korean)
NumbersCortés, Letters from MexicoFlorentine Codexa는 2시간에 3,000여 명 사망이라 적음, b는 수를 적지 않음

Place: Cholula

Show on the map — open Bernal Díaz, True History of the Conquest of New Spain