Battle of Shayuan (537) — the same event in Book of Northern Qi, History of the Northern Dynasties, Book of Wei and 1 more

Book of Northern Qi: Gao Huan crossed the Yellow River at Pujin and campaigned west with 200,000 men; Yuwen Tai camped at Shayuan. Blocked by the…

What each source says

Book of Northern Qi (Bei Qishu), Annals · AD 537 · 沙苑(大荔)

Gao Huan crossed the Yellow River at Pujin and campaigned west with 200,000 men; Yuwen Tai camped at Shayuan. Blocked by the terrain, Gao's army withdrew, and the western army advanced beating drums, causing great chaos. 180,000 suits of armor and weapons were abandoned, and Gao Huan returned by camel and boat (Battle of Shayuan).

十月壬辰,神武西討,自蒲津濟,衆二十萬。周文軍於沙苑
Location: 北齊書 卷2

History of the Northern Dynasties (Beishi), Annals · AD 537 · 沙苑

Gao Huan, Prince of Bohai, set out on a western expedition and was defeated at Shayuan.

壬辰,勃海王高歡西討,敗於沙苑
Location: 北史 卷5 東魏天平4年

Book of Wei (Weishu), Imperial Annals · AD 537 · 沙苑

Gao Huan reached Shayuan, but at a disadvantage he withdrew.

壬辰,齊獻武王西討,至沙苑,不克而還。
Location: 魏書卷12·天平四年

Book of Zhou (Zhoushu), Imperial Annals · AD 537 · 沙苑

At Shayuan (Weiqu) he ambushes in the reed beds, rises at the drum, crushes Qi Shenwu's army, kills 6,000 and receives the surrender of over 20,000

兵將交,太祖鳴鼓,士皆奮起。
Location: 周書 卷2 大統3年10月

Where the sources differ

A and B are two of the sources listed above.

On what pointSource ASource BWhat differs (in Korean)
NumbersBook of Northern Qi (Bei Qishu), AnnalsHistory of the Northern Dynasties (Beishi), Annalsa 20만, 갑옷 18만 버림 / b 수 없음

Place: 沙苑(大荔)

Show on the map — open Book of Northern Qi (Bei Qishu), Annals