Xiangyang (1273) — the same event in History of Song, History of Yuan and Xu Zizhi Tongjian

History of Song: Jia Sidao first reported that Lü Wenhuan, commander of Xiangyang, had surrendered the city to the Yuan.; History of Yuan: Lü…

What each source says

History of Song (Songshi), Annals · AD 1273 · 襄陽

Jia Sidao first reported that Lü Wenhuan, commander of Xiangyang, had surrendered the city to the Yuan.

戊寅,賈似道始奏李庭芝表言襄帥呂文煥以城降大元。
Location: 宋史卷046 咸淳九年

History of Yuan (Yuanshi), Annals · AD 1273 · 襄陽

Lü Wenhuan, Song's Jingxi pacification commissioner and prefect of Xiangyang, offered the city and surrendered.

丁未,宋京西安撫使、知襄陽府呂文煥以城降。
Location: 元史 卷8 世祖 1273年

Xu Zizhi Tongjian (Continuation of the Comprehensive Mirror) · AD 1273 · 襄陽

In the second month, day gengxu, Lü Wenhuan, Jingxi pacification deputy commissioner, surrendered Xiangyang to the Yuan.

庚戌,京西安撫副使呂文煥以襄陽叛降元
Location: 권180 二月 단락180.5.0

Place: 襄陽

Show on the map — open History of Song (Songshi), Annals