Battle of Songshan (1641) — the same event in Annals of the Joseon Dynasty and History of Ming

Annals of the Joseon Dynasty: The battle between Ming and Qing and the damage suffered by our side.; History of Ming: At the battle of Songshan, Wu…

What each source says

Annals of the Joseon Dynasty · AD 1641 · 松山堡

The battle between Ming and Qing and the damage suffered by our side.

○甲午/大明兵, 與淸人戰不利, 騎兵走入松山堡, 步兵乘船而走, 寧遠、杏塔之間, 死者相屬。 時, 祖大壽在錦州, 被圍已累月, 天朝大發兵出援, 軍門洪承疇年少自用, 不聽群言, 以至於敗。 大壽送人于淸陣曰: "被圍已九朔矣。 願速交戰, 以決勝負。" 汗不聽。 是役也, 我軍死者二十餘人, 馬斃者十八九, 所
Location: 仁祖實錄 十九年 · 仁祖實錄 42책 42권 33장 A면 · 기사 wpa_11909021_001

History of Ming (Mingshi), Annals · AD 1641 · 松山

At the battle of Songshan, Wu Sangui and Wang Pu fled, and the various armies were destroyed overnight.

總兵官吳三桂、王樸自松山遁,諸軍夜潰
Location: 明史 卷24 崇禎十四年

Place: 開京 · 松山

Show on the map — open Annals of the Joseon Dynasty