Anding (428) — the same event in History of the Northern Dynasties and Zizhi Tongjian

History of the Northern Dynasties: Xi Jin advanced on Anding; An Jie sallied out and captured Helian Chang. (The remnants set up Helian Ding and fled…

What each source says

History of the Northern Dynasties (Beishi), Annals · AD 428 · 安定

Xi Jin advanced on Anding; An Jie sallied out and captured Helian Chang. (The remnants set up Helian Ding and fled to Pingliang.)

司空奚斤進軍安定。監軍侍御史安頡出戰，禽昌
Location: 北史卷2 神䴥元年

Zizhi Tongjian (Comprehensive Mirror) · AD 428 · 安定

Xia's Xia zhou Helian Chang attacked the Northern Wei army and was thrown from his horse and captured.

夏主馬蹶而墜，遂擒之
Location: 卷121

Place: 安定

Show on the map — open History of the Northern Dynasties (Beishi), Annals