Battle of Qiuchi (442) — the same event in History of the Southern Dynasties, Book of Song, Book of Wei and 1 more

History of the Southern Dynasties: Liu Zhendao and Pei Fangming defeated Yang Nandang and pacified Qiuchi.; Book of Song: Liu Zhendao and Pei…

What each source says

History of the Southern Dynasties (Nanshi), Annals · AD 442 · 仇池

Liu Zhendao and Pei Fangming defeated Yang Nandang and pacified Qiuchi.

梁秦二州刺史劉真道、龍驤將軍裴方明破楊難當,仇池平
Location: 南史 卷2 元嘉19年

Book of Song (Songshu), Annals · AD 442 · 仇池

Liu Zhendao and Pei Fangming defeated Yang Nandang, and Qiuchi was pacified.

五月庚寅,梁秦二州刺史劉真道、龍驤將軍裴方明破氐楊難當,仇池平。
Location: 宋書 卷5 元嘉19年 5月

Book of Wei (Weishu), Imperial Annals · AD 442 · 上邽

The Song general Pei Fangming invaded to the south; Yang Nandang was defeated and fled to Shanggui.

閏月,劉義隆龍驤將軍裴方明、梁州刺史劉康祖寇南秦,南秦王楊難當敗,奔於上邽。
Location: 魏書卷4下·太平真君三年

Zizhi Tongjian (Comprehensive Mirror) · AD 442 · 仇池

Song's Pei Fangming takes Wuxing and Xiabian, defeats Yang Nandang, who flees to Shanggui, and pacifies Qiuchi (May).

仇池平
Location: 卷124

Where the sources differ

A and B are two of the sources listed above.

On what pointSource ASource BWhat differs (in Korean)
PlaceHistory of the Southern Dynasties (Nanshi), AnnalsBook of Wei (Weishu), Imperial Annalsa: 구지(仇池) 평정 / b: 양난당이 상규로 도주
WhoHistory of the Southern Dynasties (Nanshi), AnnalsBook of Wei (Weishu), Imperial Annalsa: 유진도·배방명 / b: 배방명(남진 공격)

Place: 仇池 · 秦州

Show on the map — open History of the Southern Dynasties (Nanshi), Annals