Battle of Nisibis (217) — the same event in Cassius Dio and Herodian, History of the Empire

Cassius Dio: Artabanus invaded Mesopotamia; Macrinus marched toward Nisibis and lost a battle that began over water sources, and his camp was saved…

What each source says

Cassius Dio, Roman History · AD 217 · Nisibis

Artabanus invaded Mesopotamia; Macrinus marched toward Nisibis and lost a battle that began over water sources, and his camp was saved by the baggage carriers

Macrinus had no opportunity even for deliberation, but encountering him as he was already approaching Nisibis, was defeated in a battle that was begun by
Location: 79(78).26

Herodian, History of the Empire · AD 217 · Nisibis

Macrinus's army confronts the Parthians and scatters caltrops that injure camels and cavalry. Bodies pile up like mountains, and both sides withdraw.

Location: 4.15

Where the sources differ

A and B are two of the sources listed above.

On what pointSource ASource BWhat differs (in Korean)
OutcomeCassius Dio, Roman HistoryHerodian, History of the Empirea는 마크리누스 패배, b는 양측 물러남

Place: Nisibis

Show on the map — open Cassius Dio, Roman History