Battle of Sluys (1340) — the same event in Chronicles of Jean Froissart and Giovanni Villani

Chronicles of Jean Froissart: Naval battle off Sluys (L'Écluse): the English king's fleet defeats the Norman and French fleet. Hues Kiérès and…

What each source says

Chronicles of Jean Froissart · AD 1340 · Sluys (L'Écluse)

Naval battle off Sluys (L'Écluse): the English king's fleet defeats the Norman and French fleet. Hues Kiérès and Pierres Bahucès, among others, are killed; Barbenoire flees by boat.

Geste bataille fu en l'an de grâce Notre-Seigneur mil CCC.XL, le jour devant le vegille Saint-Jean-Baptiste.
Location: L1989~1990

Chronicles of Jean Froissart · AD 1340 · Sluys

The English fleet of Edward III crushed the French fleet off Sluys (l'Escluse). The source says more than 40,000 died.

laquelle bataille fu Tan de grâce Nostre-Seigneur mil IIIc et XL , la nuit Saint-Jehan-Baptiste
Location: L1648–L1668

Chronicles of Jean Froissart · AD 1340 · L'Escluse (Sluys)

Naval battle off L'Écluse (Sluys): they fought ship to ship, and Hues Kiërës, Pierres Bahucès and others died.

Geste bataille dont je vous parolle, fu moult felenesse et
Location: l.255–308

Giovanni Villani, Nuova Cronica · AD 1340 · Sluys

Edward III defeats the French fleet in a night naval battle off Sluis; most of it is sunk or captured

Location: L.XI c.CX

Where the sources differ

A and B are two of the sources listed above.

On what pointSource ASource BWhat differs (in Korean)
OutcomeChronicles of Jean FroissartGiovanni Villani, Nuova Cronicaa: 키에레·바위셰 전사 / b: 함대 대부분 침몰·포로, 야간 전투

Place: Sluis (l'Escluse)

Show on the map — open Chronicles of Jean Froissart