Roma (190) — the same event in Cassius Dio, Herodian, History of the Empire and Historia Augusta

Cassius Dio: During a famine, a riot erupted at the circus when children led by a girl shouted; terrified, Commodus had Cleander and his son killed…

What each source says

Cassius Dio, Roman History · AD 190 · Roma

During a famine, a riot erupted at the circus when children led by a girl shouted; terrified, Commodus had Cleander and his son killed, and the crowd dragged their bodies about

And Commodus was so terrified (he was ever the greatest coward) that he at once ordered Cleander to be slain, and likewise his son, who was being reared in the…
Location: 73(72).13.6

Herodian, History of the Empire · AD 190 · Rome

The mob marches on the suburban villa demanding Cleander; cavalry cut them down while citizens throw stones and tiles from the rooftops. Street fighting erupts in Rome.

that But they who any Regard d in the City, alarmed at the Misfortune of their Fellow-Citizens, took to their Houfes j and having barred their Door up to the…
Location: 1.12

Herodian, History of the Empire · AD 190 · Rome

His sister Fadilla runs to Commodus and begs him to hand over the cause of the disaster. Cleander is beheaded, his head paraded on a spear, and the riot subsides.

proach, he was feized-, and his Head, being itruck off, and faftened on a long Spear, was carried out and expofed to public Viewa very plead ng and defirable…
Location: 1.13

Historia Augusta · AD 190 · Rome

Unable to withstand the angry citizens, Commodus hands Cleander over to the crowd to be punished

Sed et Cleandro dignus tandem vitae finis impositus. nam cum insidiis illius Arrius Antoninus fictis criminibus in Attali gratiam, quem in proconsulatu Asiae…
Location: Comm. 7.1

Where the sources differ

A and B are two of the sources listed above.

On what pointSource ASource BWhat differs (in Korean)
OutcomeHerodian, History of the EmpireHistoria Augustaa는 군중과 시가전, b는 황제가 군중에게 넘김

Place: Rome

Show on the map — open Cassius Dio, Roman History