Roma (211) — the same event in Cassius Dio, Herodian, History of the Empire and Historia Augusta

Cassius Dio: Antoninus rushed to the camp and showered the soldiers with promises, then killed some 20,000 freedmen and soldiers (men and women) of…

What each source says

Cassius Dio, Roman History · AD 211 · Roma

Antoninus rushed to the camp and showered the soldiers with promises, then killed some 20,000 freedmen and soldiers (men and women) of Geta's party in the palace, and murdered notables such as Papinianus

Of the imperial freedmen and soldiers who had been with Geta he immediately put to death some twenty thousand, men and women alike, wherever in the palace any…
Location: 78(77).4.1

Herodian, History of the Empire · AD 212 · Rome

Caracalla kills a great many of Geta's associates, including the praetorian prefect and jurist Papinian.

Location: 4.6

Historia Augusta · AD 212 · Rome

Patruinus is killed in front of the Temple of Pius, and Papinian and his son (a quaestor) are also killed, their bodies dragged through the streets

occisus est etiam eius iussu Patruinus ante templum Divi Pii, tractaque sunt eorum per plateam cadavera sine aliqua humanitatis reverentia. filium etiam…
Location: Carac. 4.2

Where the sources differ

A and B are two of the sources listed above.

On what pointSource ASource BWhat differs (in Korean)
OutcomeHerodian, History of the EmpireHistoria Augustab는 파피니아누스 아들도 살해됐다고 적음
NumbersCassius Dio, Roman HistoryHerodian, History of the Empirea 약 2만 명, b는 수많은 사람
OutcomeCassius Dio, Roman HistoryHistoria Augustab는 파피니아누스의 아들도 살해되고 시신이 끌려다녔다고 적음

Place: Rome

Show on the map — open Cassius Dio, Roman History