Hulao (423) — the same event in History of the Northern Dynasties, History of the Southern Dynasties, Book of Song and 2 more

History of the Northern Dynasties: Hulao, held by the Song general Mao Dezu, fell after a long siege and the cutting off of its water supply…

What each source says

History of the Northern Dynasties (Beishi), Annals · AD 423 · 武牢

Hulao, held by the Song general Mao Dezu, fell after a long siege and the cutting off of its water supply.

己未,武牢潰
Location: 北史 卷1 泰常8年

History of the Southern Dynasties (Nanshi), Annals · AD 423 · 虎牢

The Northern Wei army took Hulao (intercalary fourth month).

夏閏四月己未,魏軍克虎牢
Location: 南史 卷1 景平1年

Book of Song (Songshu), Annals · AD 423 · 虎牢

Wei troops took Hulao and captured Mao Dezu, Governor of Sizhou, and led him away.

乙未,魏軍克虎牢,執司州刺史毛德祖以歸。
Location: 宋書 卷4 景平1年 4月

Book of Wei (Weishu), Imperial Annals · AD 423 · 虎牢

He besieged Hulao, cut off its water supply and took it; the Song governor of Sizhou, Mao Dezu, was captured.

虎牢潰,獲劉義符冠軍將軍、司州刺史、觀陽伯毛德祖,冠軍司馬、滎陽太守翟廣,建威將軍竇霸,振武將軍姚勇錯,振威將軍吳寶之,司州別駕姜元興,治中竇溫。
Location: 魏書卷3·泰常八年

Zizhi Tongjian (Comprehensive Mirror) · AD 423 · 虎牢

Northern Wei's Xi Jin and others besieged Hulao for two hundred days, drying up the wells; it fell in the intercalary fourth month, and Mao Dezu was captured.

魏仍急攻之,己未,城陷
Location: 卷119

Where the sources differ

A and B are two of the sources listed above.

On what pointSource ASource BWhat differs (in Korean)
WhoHistory of the Southern Dynasties (Nanshi), AnnalsBook of Wei (Weishu), Imperial Annalsb는 송 사주자사 毛德祖 포로를 적음

Place: 虎牢

Show on the map — open History of the Northern Dynasties (Beishi), Annals