Xuanhu (450) — the same event in History of the Northern Dynasties, History of the Southern Dynasties, Book of Song and 2 more

History of the Northern Dynasties: On the southern campaign, the imperial carriage set out to attack Xuanhu.; History of the Southern Dynasties: The…

What each source says

History of the Northern Dynasties (Beishi), Annals · AD 450 · 懸瓠

On the southern campaign, the imperial carriage set out to attack Xuanhu.

車駕遂征懸瓠
Location: 北史 卷2 太平真君11年

History of the Southern Dynasties (Nanshi), Annals · AD 450 · 縣瓠

The Northern Wei army attacked Xianhu (the military expenses cut one-third of the officials' salaries).

魏軍攻縣瓠
Location: 南史 卷2 元嘉27年

Book of Song (Songshu), Annals · AD 450 · 懸瓠

Wei invaded several commanderies of Runan and attacked Xuanhu City; Chen Xian, in charge of Runan, defended it.

索虜攻懸瓠城,行汝南郡事陳憲拒之。
Location: 宋書 卷5 元嘉27年 2月

Book of Wei (Weishu), Imperial Annals · AD 450 · 懸瓠

He set out to campaign against Xuanhu.

車駕遂征懸瓠,益遣使者安慰境外之民,其不服者誅之。
Location: 魏書卷4下·太平真君十一年

Zizhi Tongjian (Comprehensive Mirror) · AD 450 · 汝南

Emperor Taiwu besieges Xuanhu (Runan) day and night, but Song's Chen Xian holds out for 42 days.

魏人晝夜攻懸瓠,多作高樓,臨城以射之,矢下如雨
Location: 卷125

Where the sources differ

A and B are two of the sources listed above.

On what pointSource ASource BWhat differs (in Korean)
OutcomeHistory of the Southern Dynasties (Nanshi), AnnalsBook of Song (Songshu), Annalsb는 진헌이 막았다고 적음

Place: 豫州(懸瓠·汝南)

Show on the map — open History of the Northern Dynasties (Beishi), Annals